Threats and recommended actions

Brown bear, although a charismatic and majestic species shared the dramatic fate of wolf, lynx and other large carnivores in most of the European countries. In the past, the main cause of brown bear mortality in Poland (or more generally in the Western Carpathians) was the intentional and official killing by people.

Since 1952, when the brown bear became a protected species, the cases of legal culling and trapping aiming to eliminate individual bears have been extremely rare in Poland. However, the main causes of bear mortality in Poland seems to be still of human origin. The cases of illegal killing or poaching are suspected to be still relatively common nowadays.

photo: Tomasz Zwijacz-Kozica

Recently, human disturbance is becoming an increasingly important cause of bear mortality. The increased access and disturbance of forest areas inhabited by bears due to forestry and hunting, antler gathering, tourism, recreation and sport, mainly winter sports, together with the shortage of areas free of disturbance where the animals could find refuge, is an important problem. Activities like picking forest fruits, especially bilberries, not only disturb bears, but also reduce their food resources. A relevant cause of cub mortality is den abandonment by the female due to human disturbance. In the last decades several such cases were recorded in Beskid Żywiecki and Bieszczady region. Den abandonment was mainly caused by gathering of red deer antlers, but also by forestry works and hunting. Traffic accidents are still of less importance in Poland, but an increase may be expected in the close future. Given the limited numbers of brown bears in Poland, each mortality event most probably represents a significant loss for the population.

The brown bear population in Poland is transboundary and, thus, it status depends to a great extent on the brown bear management in Slovakia. The goals of the protection and regulatory bear culling in Slovakia are the elimination of problem bears and the control of the bear population, respectively. In the last years (2000-2009), in Slovakia 277 bears were harvested under the regulatory culling and 44 under the protection culling. Culling represents 70% of the bear mortality in Slovakia. Evidence shows that it may affect bears living in the Polish territory and therefore, also the conservation status of the population in Poland. We propose a close cooperation between Slovakia and Poland in this issue to commonly design the border areas where bear culling should not be allowed, with special attention to the potential reconnection of the western and eastern segments of the population.

The damages caused by brown bears in Poland are not very numerous, and significantly lower than those produced by other protected species. Whereas the number of bear damages is low and stable in Śląskie and Małopolskie Voivodships (compensation costs of about few thousand PLN), in the Podkarpackie Voivodship the number of damages has been increasing in the last decade and damage compensations reached 250,000 PLN in 2010. Most bear damages concern apiaries.